Reviews

In their own words.

5.020 reviews from paying Skool members
★★★★★
Exceptional tool for completing broken stories! Ideorix makes taking a book from initial draft to publication smoother than ever. The editorial pipeline gives me complete peace of mind before publishing, and the Story Room is fantastic for working through tricky plot points and developing ideas. Whether you write every word yourself or use AI as a creative partner, this software delivers top-tier results without any technical headaches. 5 stars!
Andrew Westcott · still a paying member after 5 months
★★★★★
A unique and powerful suite of author tools for AI; there is nothing like it. Jim has shared his Computer editing and writing skills with us all. May you have many hours of happy writing when you open the magic box.
Paul Rutherford · still a paying member after 7 months
★★★★★
A relaxed approach to a complex subject. He and his team are there for you when you need them. A fascinating system to examine and incorporate into your work if you choose to walk that path.
John Scanlan · still a paying member after 3 months
★★★★★
I have been using Ideorix for 4 weeks now and it is an amazing product. I can't believe how useful I have found it. I would recommend you join the Skool and see how much it will help you.
Colin Maddocks · still a paying member after 3 months
★★★★★
Learning so much and it's paying off! Working smarter and faster - not harder!
Amy Pierce · still a paying member after 3 months
★★★★★
I am having a great time here. Everyone's really nice.
Christina Whisler · still a paying member after 3 months
★★★★★
Fantastic tool, Great community and Jim is a Gem!!!
Mark McCarthy-Smith · still a paying member after 6 months
★★★★★
A very helpful community! And good content.
Tomas Arfert · still a paying member after 4 months
★★★★★
Totally amazing and totally worth it
Diana Wolf · still a paying member after 5 months
★★★★★
Love what Jim has created here!
Michael Culp · still a paying member after 5 months

Also rated five stars, without a written comment:

  • Dawn M · 7 months
  • Dom Ioanna · 6 months
  • Vmae Bryant · 5 months
  • Paul Jönsson · 5 months
  • Michael Kogut · 5 months
  • Dora Guerra · 5 months
  • Dennis Schmidt · 4 months
  • Don White · 3 months
  • Costas Damianou · 2 months
  • Eryn Wright · 2 months

Reviews as published in the IDEORIX Skool community, autumn 2026.


The Long Reviews

Two early testers. Nothing softened.

Both writers volunteered as unpaid early testers of IDEORIX Fiction and were free to say exactly what they found, caveats included.

Review · Screenwriter

"I've tried them all. Ideorix beat them all."

Eric: twenty-plus years in screenwriting, sixteen of them teaching the craft. Unpaid early tester.

Nobody paid me for this. I'm paying it forward.

Twenty-plus years in screenwriting, sixteen of them teaching the craft. When I started using AI to assist my writing, the work was novelization: taking my screenplays and building them out to prose. Claude paired with NovelCrafter handled that well. Drafting was never the problem.

Editing was the problem. NovelCrafter, RaptorWrite, even the Story Hacker OS — all of them go soft in the same place. The draft finishes and the real work starts, and suddenly you're bolting on outside tools, exporting, re-importing, losing the thread. Worse, every question you ask mid-process means leaving the workflow. You break momentum to get an answer, then spend twenty minutes finding your place again. I've researched nearly every AI writing platform out there. Same weakness, different logo.

Ideorix is the first one that doesn't have it.

It runs inside Claude's ecosystem, and that architecture changes the working experience. Stop mid-chapter, ask a craft question, get your answer, and the system picks up exactly where it left off. No lost place. No re-orienting. The workflow bends around you instead of the other way around.

The editorial back office is what sold me. This isn't a spell-checker wearing a trench coat. Dev editor, line editor, copy editor, a twelve-step editing pipeline, and a five-lens beta panel built from established real-person reading habits. Continuity and timeline checks that catch the contradiction you buried in chapter 19 and forgot about. All of it built against real editorial standards, not vibes.

It runs the whole line: setup, Story Bible, chapter by chapter drafting, then the full editorial pass, cover design, and book blurbs on the back end. You don't leave the system to finish the book.

Here's the practical math. Plant yourself in the seat five hours a day, uninterrupted, and you can produce a fully edited novel in six days. Covers and blurbs included. I taught story structure for sixteen years. I know what a clean manuscript costs in time. This is not a small number.

Full disclosure: I'm helping design the screenplay adaptation module, which is still being tweaked. I volunteered because after testing everything else on the market, this was the system worth building on.

One caveat. It eats tokens. A Max plan gets you the full benefit. A patient author can run it on Pro.

I've tried them all. Ideorix beat them all. That's the whole review.

Eric

Review · Published Author

"A powerhouse story production platform without equal today."

Mitch: published author of twenty-some volumes. Unpaid early tester.

I am a published author of 20-some volumes, and I'm currently working on several more. I use AI collaboration in most stages of my work these days, and have done so since early 2025.

My first writing platform was NovelCrafter, and I found that to be serviceable. Using that system, I can produce a finished work in 3–4 weeks of long work days (usually 14 hours). There is a lot of editing required after the draft is done, using other tools, as NovelCrafter doesn't have native editing functionality.

I have tried Raptor Write, BookNova, Co-Author, and several other book production systems since late 2025. None of them matched NovelCrafter with my workflow, but given the rapidly changing landscape in fiction production, I kept looking.

I met Jim Montgomery, developer of the Ideorix Manuscript System, via Jason Hamilton's Skool community (now called Story Hackers AI). Once I learned Jim was building a fiction writing platform, I volunteered to be a dev tester for him (unpaid). Although Ideorix was not complete when I started, I fell in love with it right away.

With Ideorix, I have written short stories, novellas, and one novel from scratch. I have also revised some of my previously published works, as I knew they needed some housekeeping. I have also imported partially-complete works from other sources and finished those stories in Ideorix.

It is a superior platform to any I have tested. Indeed, I have left NovelCrafter for Ideorix.

Ideorix is a harness that runs in the Anthropic ecosystem. I was already a fan and heavy user of Anthropic LLMs, so this fit well for me. Inside their desktop system, the Cowork interface works best for me, and is ideal for Ideorix. I started with a Pro plan, and I have moved to a Max plan. Although this increased my monthly costs, the increase in speed and quality has been more than worth it for me. I can now finish a full novel, from concept to publishable document, in 7–10 days. Short stories take 2–3 days. Overall, my productivity has about tripled since I started using Ideorix.

The functions in Ideorix that I don't find in other platforms include a full editing process (12–14 major steps, depending on my choices), a market survey subsystem that helps me position my work in the marketplace, and a cover prompt generator that gives me options directly from analyzing my finished work. The main point is, I don't have to leave Ideorix to do all the work on a book — with one exception: generating the final book cover images, which I do myself.

Because of the way Cowork behaves, I can add rules, templates, and special instructions (for a single book or globally) to the way Ideorix functions. This customization isn't available in any platform I have tested so far. I can ask any question of the LLM at any time, and it never loses its place in the workflow of the harness. Jim has worked hard to be sure that AI-isms are excluded, that all the editing functions are well-behaved (dev edit, line edit, copy edit, proofing, alpha/beta readers), and the beta-reader function is actually performed by five different personalities. I have added a sixth personality that I like, and Ideorix has no issue with using a council of six for this work.

One last item I'm learning to enjoy and rely on: Ideorix has a Second Brain function (separate plugin). As I finish a piece, I invoke the Brain and put the story bible and finished prose in there. Each story becomes an indexed part of a database I can query when I'm working on future stories. This speeds up my internal research, and provides canon quality control for planned works. The Brain isn't limited to Ideorix-generated pieces: I can add any files, at any time, and it will index them and correlate to existing materials. I have thousands of files of older story starts and research I plan to use in novels going forward. I know established authors sometimes hire archivists just to have this function. My Second Brain will do this for me for a fraction of the cost, faster, and with fewer mistakes than any human archivist.

There are many details I have left out: genre identification and hybrid/blended genre development; ease of importing, restarting, and exporting work; an Author's Voice builder; pen names management; and so on. The ease with which an author can work in Ideorix is worth mentioning — I've never had to look at the manual.

In conclusion, I believe the Ideorix Manuscript System, with its Second Brain, is a powerhouse story production platform without equal today.

Mitch

Ready to write at a higher standard?

Less Prompting. More Publishing.